Capacity Building Commission

India’s Trade Ambitions Need an Entrepreneurial State

India’s Trade Ambitions Need an Entrepreneurial State


Referring to the India-United Kingdom (UK) Free Trade Agreement (FTA), the Chief Economic Advisor of India, Dr. V. Anantha Nageswaran noted that there remains a substantial gap between what FTAs promise and what domestic regulations currently permit. Trade agreements may open doors in external markets, but whether Indian firms can walk through those doors depends on what the State enables at home.

A trade agreement may cut tariffs and expand market access. But converting that access into exports depends on a much wider ecosystem: customs processes, sectoral regulations, and frontline officials who interpret rules on the ground (Deardorff, 2012). The real question is not whether India can get better deals for itself through such agreements. It is whether the Indian State is organised to coordinate across departments, reduce regulatory friction, take decisions under uncertainty, and respond quickly when implementation gaps appear.

From Compliance to Mission Capability

India’s administrative system has delivered stability, continuity and reform at scale by valuing procedure, accountability and rule-based functioning (Government of India, Ministry of Finance, 2026). These remain essential strengths. The next step is to complement them with the organizational capacity required for mission-oriented delivery under such FTAs.

Many of India's economic priorities no longer fit within the mandate of one ministry (Government of India, Ministry of Finance, 2026, Chapter 16). Consider the implementation of an FTA: while market access may be negotiated by the Ministry of Commerce, translating it into actual gains requires customs authorities, sectoral Ministries/Departments and State governments to act in alignment. They require the government to work as a system, not as separate units. This should be achieved through a focus on building organisational capacity within the government.

Organisational capacity is the bridge between policy intent and tangible outcomes. It depends on how organisations are structured, staffed and equipped to deliver. Roles and responsibilities must be aligned to outcomes. Organisations must also have access to specialist expertise, analytical support and reliable data. Processes must support coordination across organisational boundaries and organizations must be able to use feedback from implementation to improve decisions. It is therefore not simply the sum of the competencies held by individual officials, but the institutional environment within which those competencies are exercised.

This is why the capacity-building agenda under Mission Karmayogi matters. Its remit is not limited to individual competencies. It also seeks to help organisations absorb those competencies through better systems, processes and role clarity. Otherwise, trained officials return to unchanged systems.

Becoming an Entrepreneurial State

Building such organizational capacity is the institutional foundation of an entrepreneurial state. An entrepreneurial State does not replace markets, nor does it act with unchecked discretion. It acts under uncertainty, structures risk, convenes actors, learns from implementation and corrects course when required. Firms can invest and compete only when public systems are predictable, responsive and able to solve coordination problems.

The Economic Survey 2025-26 places this requirement in the context of a more uncertain and segmented global economy. Stability, prudence and democratic legitimacy remain essential. But they must now be complemented by the ability to coordinate across institutional boundaries, exercise judgement under uncertainty and revise decisions when evidence changes. These capabilities depend on organizational design, not individual initiative alone (Ministry of Finance, 2026, Chapter 16). 

Several trade-oriented economies built exactly this capability. Japan's post-war industrial rise rested on bureaucratic authority anchored in sectoral outcomes and institutional learning. Officials were not punished for every failed bet; what mattered was sound reasoning and whether the system learned. South Korea combined support with discipline: firms received credit and protection but tied to demanding export performance and credible withdrawal when results fell short. Singapore treated regulatory speed and credibility as economic assets. Rules could adapt to facilitate investment, but once standards were set, enforcement was strict and predictable (Johnson, 1982; Amsden, 1989). 

These models cannot be transplanted wholesale into India’s democratic and federal system. Their common lesson is nevertheless relevant: entrepreneurial states are built through institutional arrangements that combine outcome orientation, learning and accountability to change course.

A Way Forward

A practical framework for building this capacity was proposed by the Chief Economic Advisor in his keynote lecture during Sadhana Saptah 2026 on 2 April (Press Information Bureau, 2026). His central proposition was not that the entire bureaucracy must become entrepreneurial. Routine administration will continue to require stability and predictability. Instead, the government should create bounded spaces in which entrepreneurial action is possible. 

  • The first is clear outcome ownership. In cross-cutting priorities, responsibility is spread across institutions, but accountability is diffused. Departments may keep their schemes and resources, but there must be one identifiable centre responsible for sequencing actions and reporting progress.
  • The second is entrepreneurial safe spaces: regulatory sandboxes, time-bound pilots and mission cells where experimentation is permitted and accountability is defined in advance. These are not exemptions from accountability. They are spaces where accountability is suited to uncertainty.
  • The third is what the CEA called an architecture of forgiveness. This does not mean tolerating corruption or negligence. It means distinguishing between good-faith error, design failure and malfeasance, and judging decisions against the information available at the time. Without this, officials will prefer delay over decision.

Mission Karmayogi and the Capacity Building Commission can play an enabling role in this transition (Press Trust of India, 2026). The next phase of capacity building must support both individual capability and organizational capacity. This means helping ministries and departments identify the roles, competencies, do systems-diagnostics and government process reengineering required for mission-oriented delivery. It also means designing capacity-building interventions that are linked to real institutional priorities, rather than individual training alone.

For example, officials working on trade, regulation, AI or procurement require specialized capabilities. But these capabilities will matter only if institutions also provide clear mandates, data systems, feedback loops, legal support, continuity in critical roles and mechanisms for cross-departmental coordination. This is where CBC’s work on organizational capacity building becomes important: enabling public organisations to absorb individual competencies into better ways of working.

If India builds such capacity deliberately, its trade agreements will become more than promises on paper. The doors that FTAs open abroad will finally be matched by the ability, at home, to walk through them.

 

AI disclosure: The author used ChatGPT to support editing, improve clarity, and refine the structure of this article. The ideas, analysis, and conclusions are the author's own, and the final text was reviewed and approved by the author.

 

References:

Mustafa Rasheed is Team Lead for Policy at the Capacity Building Commission. Views expressed are personal.